Many Prostitutes Suffer
Combat Disorder, Study Finds
by Abigail Zuger
Copyright © August
18, 1998
The New York Times. All Rights Reserved.
The world's oldest profession
may also be among its most traumatizing.
A new study has found that a serious psychiatric
illness resulting from exposure to physical
danger is more common among prostitutes
than among troops who have weathered combat
duty.
The illness, post-traumatic
stress disorder, is the modern equivalent
of shell shock, or combat fatigue. It leaves
survivors of serious physical danger emotionally
numb, and tortured by recurrent nightmares
and flashbacks, often for decades.
In a study to be presented
today at the annual meeting of the American
Psychological Association in San Francisco,
researchers interviewed almost 500 prostitutes
from around the world and discovered that
two-thirds suffered from post-traumatic
stress disorder. In contrast, the condition
is found in less than 5 percent of the
general population. Studies of veterans
of combat in the Vietnam War have found
that the disorder may be diagnosed in 20
percent to 30 percent, about half of whom
have long-term psychiatric problems.
"Essentially, we
need to view prostitution itself as a traumatic
stressor," said Dr.
Melissa Farley,
a psychologist and researcher at the Kaiser-Permanente
Medical Center in San Francisco who directed
the study with colleagues from Turkey and
Africa.
Dr. Farley's team interviewed
male and female prostitutes ranging in
age from 12 to 61 who operated on the street
and in brothels in San Francisco and six
large cities in Europe, Asia and Africa.
The vast majority reported having sustained
recurrent physical or sexual assaults in
working hours.
Using a severity scale
developed by scientists who study post-traumatic
stress in the military, Dr. Farley's team
found that the prostitutes averaged a slightly
more severe form of the disease than even
Vietnam veterans seeking treatment for
the condition. That is an "enormously
high" rating on the scale, said Dr.
Matthew Friedman, executive director of
the Department of Veterans' Affairs National
Center for post-traumatic stress disorder
and a professor of psychiatry at Dartmouth
Medical School.
The frequency of post-traumatic
stress disorder among the prostitutes appeared
to be unrelated to their nationality or
where they worked. It was as common in
Istanbul as in San Francisco, and as common
among the men and women working in three
expensive brothels in Johannesburg as among
those working in the streets of that city,
even though less physical violence occurred
in the brothels, Dr. Farley said.
Hers is the first study
of post-traumatic stress in prostitutes,
but other studies have shown similarly
high frequencies of the disorder in other
disadvantaged groups of women, including
pregnant drug users, and homeless and battered
women.
Dr. Farley also found
that about two-thirds of the prostitutes
studied complained of medical problems.
Unexpectedly, few of the problems appeared
to be related to sexually transmitted diseases,
she said. Instead, they were similar to
the medical problems researchers have found
in other groups of patients with the disorder.
In contrast to the romantic
vision of prostitution often presented
by Hollywood, "prostitution is not
just a job choice," Dr. Farley said.
More than 90 percent of the prostitutes
in her study said they "wanted out" of
that way of life. |